
By the time we got to Montana, Betty as the beautiful, confident, talented girl I had known was gone. There was no longer an individual person behind her sorrowful eyes. She had become a bi-product of Rich's abuse. She was engulfed by who he told her she was; worthless, pitiful, lying, lazy, lost, hopeless, betraying, sad wife. Being told all of these things over and over you start to believe them. You disappear behind them. Rich had gotten to the point where he would lock Betty in the house. He would search through the garbage and call her a lying cheating whore if she had used a shaver. He would stop by her work several times a day to make sure she was still there. He would take her paychecks immediately after she had received them and give her a small allowance for "spending money." Everything that went wrong was her fault. If he forgot cigarettes, she became a useless horrible person for not remembering them herself. He told her over and over that if she got pregnant he would use a skewer to poke it out of her. He was "only joking." They owned a Pit-bull Rottweiler mix and by now it had killed two dogs and put several into the animal hospital. Betty said that Rich was horribly cruel to the dog. I never got details. How could this person be my brother?
I remember one day in particular. We were driving up to a trail-head to go snowmobiling. Rich had rigged up an old trailer to his Saab. It was rickety, rusty and lacked all integrity. We wove our way over the snow coated roads skidding slightly with the each slip of the trailer. I was trying to make light conversation and mentioned that my ex-boyfriend, who Rich had only met once, had gone heli-skiing.
"Why do you always have to bring him up." Rich growled. I never talked about him.
"I don't, but he was a big part of my life, so naturally he comes up in some of my conversations.""
"He was a worthless, bad excuse for a man and you have no right to talk about him in front of me. Why do you always have to entice me. You know I don't like him." Rich's face was turning red with rage as he went on and on about how Jim had been an awful person and that I was weak and useless for liking him. It was as though me bringing him up had ruined Rich's whole life.
"Jim was a good person and you have no right to react this way because I mentioned him in a conversation."
"NO,NO, NO. Stop. Stop right now. You are an idiot. You have no idea what you are talking about. Don't mention him around me. How hard can that be?" Rich exploded, screaming through the car and ramming his fist into the dash board. My mom turned around and looked me straight in the eyes ordering,
"Erin stop making your brother angry, just stop."
This is how I had grown up thinking that it was my fault when my dad and brother would scream at me until I had no dignity left for stating an opinion different from their own. If I spilled a glass of milk, my dad would slam his fist on the table and holler at me until I felt like I was the worst person in the world. I got slapped and sat in the corner for an hour for asking the furniture man why he had so many buggers. When I was trying to get Rich to stop messing up my doll house, he turned around and punched me so hard that I couldn't stand up for ten minutes. Somehow it was always my fault for provoking them.
"Erin don't make your dad mad."
"Erin stop provoking your brother."
"Erin why did that bother you so much?" I grew up thinking that it was my fault that my brother hit me and my dad battered me with his words until I was afraid to say anything but what he wanted to hear. I got really good at figuring out exactly what they wanted to hear and saying it at all times.
At the trail-head, while we were unloading the snowmobiles from the lopsided trailer, Rich realized that he had forgotten the cigarettes. He screamed out in rage and slammed his foot into the car door turning his hateful glare on Betty.
"Where are the cigarettes!"
"I don't know I thought they were in the top of the backpack."
"I give you one simple thing to do, remember the cigarettes and you forget them. You are completely incapable. why can't you remember one thing that I tell you?" He had never mentioned cigarettes at the house. He stared down at her with a disdainful glare, as her eyes filled with tears and her voice diminished into a whisper.
"I'm sorry, I didn't mean to."
"Ya well I'm starting to not believe you."
After riding in the forest for a couple hours, we made it back to the car where we would load the snowmobiles onto the decrepit trailer. In order to get the snowmobiles onto the trailer, we had to lift the back end up so that it was at a 45 degree angle. There was no device for holding the trailer bed in place once it was tilted upward, so Rich placed a block of wood under it. We made a little ramp of snow in front of the trailer to help the runners jump over the rim of the bed. Rich made his first attempt at pulling one of the heavy machines onto the trailer. He had to get a bit of speed to make it up the 45 degree trailer bed. As he pulled towards the trailer, the front runners nicked the rim of the bed. The abrupt shock knocked out the block of wood and sent the trailer banging back into its horizontal position. Rich got very silent as he sat on the snowmobile. He never liked it when things didn't work out as planned. The cloud of anger started to build around him and seep out towards us.
"You are going to have to hold the trailer in place." Rich snarled.
Betty and I took our positions behind the trailer holding it up trying hard not to remember the violent jolt that had previously knocked it down. Rich revved towards the trailer and the front runners rammed into the bed sending a bone rattling impact up Betty's and my arms. Betty and I dropped the back of the trailer tipping the snowmobile off the end as it rose back to its horizontal position.
"What the hell are you doing! I told you to hold it in place damn it. You are so useless. Get back over there and don't let go this time."
Betty and I slunk back to our positions too afraid to disobey. The snowmobile came roaring at us again and the same thing happened this time slamming Betty's hand into the metal railing and drawing blood.
"God Damn It!!!" Rich hollers.
"I'm not doing that again. It hurt me." Betty peeps.
"Well somebody has to. It's the only way. Stop being such a wimp and just do it."
"I'll do it." My mom chimes in. She stands in Betty's place while my brother slams into the trailer two more times before actually getting the snowmobiles up. I walked away with a baseball sized bruise on my hip from the trailer slamming into me. Rich wouldn't look at Betty the rest of the evening for disobeying him. My mom never complained.
Betty only stayed with Rich a few more months after we left. She said her turning point is when she had a snowmobile accident and ran the snowmobile into a tree. As she was laying on the ground in shock, Rich ran right past her to the snowmobile grumbling about how she better not have damaged the machine. At this moment, she realized that he valued an old piece of machinery over her well being. When she got out of the hospital with a sprained wrist and severe bone bruising, Rich scolded her telling her she was never allowed to touch a snowmobile again due to her incompetence. A month later she went to a friend's house after work and never went home.
"